Skip to content

Replacing a circuit breaker: MCB, MCCB or motor protection

A failed breaker is easy to replace once you know which kind it is. What to read off the old one, what must match on the spare and what changes with a successor.
Author
Sparehawk
Reading time
4 min read
Published
  • Maintenance
  • Part numbers
  • Sourcing

First work out which kind of breaker failed. A miniature circuit breaker (MCB) is matched on rated current, trip curve, poles and breaking capacity. A moulded case circuit breaker (MCCB) adds frame size, trip unit settings and accessories. A motor protection circuit breaker is matched on its setting range and breaking capacity. Read these values off the label, then search the ordering code or request quotes with a photo of it.

A burnt or damaged breaker stops a panel as surely as a failed drive. The part itself is usually simple, but the spare has to match more than the current printed on the front. This article sorts out the three kinds you meet in machine panels and what to check for each.

Which kind of breaker failed

The kind decides which values matter. The shape and the label usually tell you.

KindProduct standardHow to recognise it
Miniature circuit breaker (MCB)IEC 60898-1Rail-mounted, a narrow module per pole, curve and current on the front, such as C16
Moulded case circuit breaker (MCCB)IEC 60947-2Larger case, bolted or plug-in, frame size and trip unit on the label
Motor protection circuit breakerIEC 60947-2 and IEC 60947-4-1Rotary knob or push buttons, setting range in amperes on a dial

Many MCBs built into machines are also certified to IEC 60947-2. That does not change what you read off them.

What to read off the old breaker

Photograph the label and the front before you remove the part. Then note:

  • The brand and the ordering code, exactly as printed, including any suffix.
  • The rated current and, on an MCB, the trip curve letter: B, C or D.
  • The number of poles, and whether the neutral is switched.
  • The rated breaking capacity in kA: Icn on an MCB, Icu and Ics on an MCCB.
  • The rated voltage, and whether the breaker is marked for AC, DC or both.
  • Every accessory fitted: auxiliary contacts, a shunt trip, an undervoltage release, a rotary handle or a motor operator.

On an MCCB with an electronic trip unit, also write down the dial settings. They are part of the protection design and are lost when the unit is swapped.

What must match on the spare

Rated current, trip curve and number of poles must match the original. The curve sets how the breaker reacts to inrush current, so a C curve is no stand-in for a D curve on a transformer or motor circuit.

Breaking capacity must be equal to or higher than the original. A lower value can look fine on paper and fail at the one fault that matters.

AC and DC are not interchangeable. A breaker marked only for AC must not replace a DC breaker. Some DC breakers are polarity sensitive, so note which terminal was connected to which side.

On a motor protection circuit breaker, the rated current of the motor must sit inside the setting range of the spare. If the breaker works with a contactor in a tested combination, check the coordination table of the manufacturer before you change brand or series.

Mounting must fit as well: the same rail, bolt pattern, busbar or comb connection, and for an MCCB the same door cut-out for the handle.

When the series is discontinued

MCBs are the easiest case. A current model from the same brand or another one usually fits, provided rating, curve, poles and breaking capacity match. Check that the busbar comb still fits the new pitch.

MCCBs and motor protection breakers are harder. A successor frame often has other dimensions, other terminals and its own accessories. Siemens, for example, moved its moulded case range from 3VL to 3VA, and the accessories of the old range do not fit the new one. Manufacturers publish replacement tables for such moves. The obsolescence guide explains how to plan them before the next failure.

How to search and request quotes

Search the ordering code on Sparehawk, with or without spaces. Where a number has been superseded, the current part and its predecessors are both shown. Each offer shows condition, country and lead time, and the price where the supplier publishes it.

A fault rarely takes out only one breaker. Put every affected breaker and its accessories in one request for quotes. It goes first to the best-matched suppliers for each line, and the quotes come back into one comparison. If the code finds nothing, work through the checks for an empty search, or post a wanted request with the photo of the label.

01

Frequently asked questions

1.1

Is a used or refurbished breaker a sensible spare?

For a small MCB a new part usually costs little, so used rarely pays off. For a large MCCB or an obsolete frame, refurbished units are common; ask the supplier what the test covered.
1.2

Are UL 1077 supplementary protectors the same as UL 489 breakers?

No. A UL 1077 device is a supplementary protector and cannot provide branch circuit protection in a UL panel. If the old part is listed to UL 489, the spare must be too.
1.3

Should a new motor protection breaker get the old dial setting?

Set it to the rated current on the motor nameplate, not to the old dial position, which may have been changed over the years.
02

All posts

    Go to